The Classics Club: The Sign of the Four


After enjoying all the previous Sherlock Holmes mysteries by Arthur Conan Doyle in quite quick succession, I just had to hold out a little for this, The Sign of the Four, my last original Holmes tale to discover for the first time.

At the beginning of this tale, we find Holmes out of his mind on boredom and drugs, and Watson at the end of his tether with him. Both are overjoyed when the young, pretty Miss Mary Morstan arrives, with the case of her missing father and the exquisite pearls that have been mysteriously gifted to her each year since his disappearance. Now, she has received a letter requesting a secret meeting to discuss how she has been ‘wronged’ and she may bring two friends. So Mary asks if Holmes and Watson will be the two to accompany her – Holmes is roused by what he calls this simple, little mystery and jumps at the chance, only to find the plot thickens at every turn.

As with the previous mysteries, I was fascinated by the workings of Holmes’ mind and his eccentric behaviour, however it is his companion Dr Watson I am always most drawn to. With his down-to-earth narration which makes these stories more relatable for me and, I am sure, many other readers too. In this tale, I particularly liked Watson’s shy, tender behaviour towards their new, pretty client Miss Mary Morstan, and the budding romance that follows – while their courtship may seem a tad too fast for us modern readers, I did believe they had genuine feelings for each other.

This may have been the last Holmes’ mystery for me to read, however it is only Doyle’s second novel to feature his famous, private sleuth. While I have read these mysteries out of order, it has not affected my enjoyment of them at all. While I think the gothic and atmospheric, The Hound of the Baskervilles is still my favourite novel, this was a still an excellently mystery and a thoroughly enjoyable read. With it’s ever twisting and multiplying threads, in fact more crimes and deaths occur, as Holmes’ is still investigating the first crime. I also enjoyed the historical links back to India and the bloody Indian Rebellion of 1857.

Overall, I thought The Sign of the Four was another excellently crafted mystery, which was a perfect read for Autumn and the R.I.P XI reading event. Now I have no new, original Holmes tales to look forward to, I better get going on more of the Mary Russell and Sherlock Holmes books. Great read.

Have you read this? What is your favourite Sherlock Holmes story?

The Classics Club – 47/50
R.eaders I.mbibing P.eril XI – 3/4


10 thoughts on “The Classics Club: The Sign of the Four

  1. I’ve only just started the Sherlock Holmes books this year but have enjoyed quite a few of his historical fictions titles – Tragedy of the Korosko, the Brigadier Gerard series, Sir Nigel & The White Company. They are all great. The Sherlock Holmes story I’ve enjoyed best so far is A Study in Scarlet, but they’ve all been good. So glad Conan Doyle was a prolific author!

    1. Hello Carol, thank you for stopping by and commenting 🙂 I am a little jealous that you only started reading the Holmes stories this year – it is magical to read them for the first time – however I hope you enjoy them as much as I did. I haven’t read anything else by Doyle though, so maybe his historical fictions will ease me my heartache over finishing all the Holmes tales 😛

  2. Jessica, I got behind on visiting the blogs I follow because of our presidential election and my chagrin over the results. Now I am catching up. You have made me want very much to read this one!

    1. Judy, I am sorry to hear you are chagrined over your presidential election results – it seems to be the year for it, with the Brexit vote here too. I hope you are able to read this soon and that it helps cheer you up…even if its just a bit!

    1. Lynn, it is so lovely that so many people are still loving these wonderful stories. Hound of the Baskervilles is both our favourite and we both love Watson – they do say great minds think a like 😛

  3. So glad you enjoyed it! I too love the Watson/Mary romance in this, especially the bit where they find themselves holding hands without conscious thought. Holmes is the hero of course, but it’s Watson who humanises the books and makes them such a pleasure to read. The Hound is my favourite of the long stories, but really I can pick up any Holmes story and read it with pleasure, just for the writing. And the good thing is they stand up well to constant re-reading!

    1. Thank you FF 🙂 I am so pleased to hear you found all these wonderful tales stood up well to constant re-read – now I am looking forward to my re-reads of them already 😀

  4. I’m glad you enjoyed your final Sherlock Holmes novel! I’m sure I read this one years ago, but I can’t remember much about it – I think I’ll have to reread it one day.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s