Re-Read: The Amber Spyglass

Over the Christmas period, I enjoyed a comforting re-read of The Amber Spyglass by Philip Pullman, the final book in Pullman’s ever popular His Dark Materials trilogy. (There is a considerable chance of spoilers in this post, so if you are unfamiliar with this series I recommend instead that you read my thoughts on the first book: Northern Lights).

Now Will is the bearer of ‘The Subtle Knife’, his father’s dying wish was for him to deliver this powerful and dangerous weapon to Lord Asriel to help in his war against ‘The Authority’. But Will couldn’t possibly think of going until he has found and rescued Lyra, from those who wish to stop her fulfilling her destiny, as Will and Lyra’s lives, loves, and fates are now irrevocably joined. Together they have their own battles to fight and inevitable journey to go on, that will even take them to the world of the dead…

And it was another real joy to follow the wild, spontaneous Lyra and the practical, selfless Will on their adventures. For me they truly are the best partners in crime and in this final book it is wonderful to see their friendship blossom into something deeper and richer. However this final book also has a lot more characters and threads, all of which have their own crucial part to play, going on at once, including: Lord Asriel, Mrs Coulter, the witch Serafina Pekkala, the armoured bear Iorek Byrnison, Dr Mary Malone and the ‘Mulefa’, Father Gomez, the angels Balthamos and Baruch and the dead…

Boy, I had forgotten just how much Pullman had stuffed into this book! On the positive side this makes for an intriguing, twisting tale which should really make for a rollercoaster ride but for me it doesn’t, and that is because many of these characters and threads have never been mentioned let alone explored in any detail in the previous books. Which for me, especially first time around, meant whole slow sections that felt like giant information dumps! Having said that though this time, being my second read, I did find it a lot easier to take everything in. However my true enjoyment still came from the simpler, central thread following Lyra and Will.

Then we come to the final epic showdown between the armies of Lord Asriel and ‘The Authority’, and Lyra facing temptation and her prophesied destiny. Through out which Pullman showcases his Atheism: making it quite clear a world, or in this case worlds, without God and/or organised religion is a better one. Now I am a practicing Christian and I have to admit there was nothing that particularly bothered or upset me about all this – if Pullman wants to be an Atheist that is up to him and his opinions won’t affect my faith. On the other hand though, I can see how people could be bothered, upset or angered by some of his views shared in this book.

So overall The Amber Spyglass is still not my favourite, however I did find it easier second time around and it is still a fitting, bitter-sweet ending to a wonderful trilogy. While I didn’t plan it, this re-read has also aligned with the release of Pullman’s sequel The Book of Dust, which I now look forward to reading! Good read.

Have you read this? Have you read the new sequel, The Book of Dust?


12 thoughts on “Re-Read: The Amber Spyglass

  1. I’m with you – I loved this series but the first was my favourite. I enjoyed the other two but the final book was probably my least favourite. Like I said, I liked it, but it maybe tried to do too much.
    Lynn 😀

    1. Lynn, I think you’ve summed it up perfectly. While it is still enjoyable, Pullman just tried to do a little too much in this final instalment. Also I think the first book is my favourite too 🙂

  2. I loved this trilogy also and plan to reread it some day, hopefully soon. I have read quite a bit of fantasy in recent months and I think these trilogies often have layers of depth that are better understood by reading them a second time. You explained that well. Of course, I also look forward to The Book of Dust. I admire and agree with your tolerance for different religious beliefs. The world would be a better place if more people felt that way!

    1. Thank you Judy 🙂 I am pleased to hear you loved these books too and that you felt my review of it did it justice. Hopefully you are able to re-read these soon and be all ready to continue with The Book of Dust.

  3. How great that despite not being your favorite entry in the saga you were still able to enjoy it more this time around. While Pullman’s atheism may not be welcomed, it goes well with the theme of the trilogy, ‘The Authority’ being a religious, constraining organization enslaving children.

    1. Carmen, it really was great that I enjoyed this more second time round. While I sort of get what you mean, I think it is not so much that Pullman’s Atheism fits the theme, but that he chose the theme because he is an Atheist. No matter though because there was nothing in the story or ideas that bothered or upset – just I could see how others could be.

    1. Hello Magpie, thank you for stopping by and commenting. It is always nice to hear from a new face, especially when they are a fan of His Dark Materials. I hope you find that good moment to read The Book of Dust soon! 😀

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.