Undivided by Vicky Beeching

As a practicing Christian, I like to read Christian literature to help with the growth of my faith and I am very lucky that my church has it’s own book club to help me with this. In May, we read and met to discuss the insightful Love Wins by Rob Bell. Next up to read was the memoir, Undivided: Coming Out, Becoming Whole, and Living Free from Shame by the Christian singer-songwriter, Vicky Beeching.

By her early thirties, Vicky was a household name: recording multiple albums; performing at Christian festivals and in America’s largest megachurches; and having her music played weekly in churches and on the radio around the world. However this poster girl for evangelical Christian music lived with a debilitating inner battle: she was gay. Knowing that the vast majority of her thousands of traditional Christian listeners were staunchly opposed to same-sex relationships and saw homosexuality as a grievous sin, Vicky feared acknowledging her sexuality even to herself, let alone telling others, as it would cost her everything.

I have to admit that Vicky’s name wasn’t instantly recognisable to me, but I have since recognised several of her songs that we use at my church. This didn’t really matter though, because this is not a tale of her fame. Instead this is a candid confession and exploration of one woman’s personal struggle with her sexuality. Starting as a young teen, Vicky takes us through years of shame, prayer, denial and even being subjected to an exorcism at a youth camp, as she tried to free herself of what she truly believed to be a sinful fault. Which led her into a lonely adult life, where she denied her feelings, took a forced celibacy, and instead lost herself in a crazy work schedule.

Then, at thirty-five, Vicky was faced with some serious health issues arising from her gruelling work load, stress and loneliness. So she made the brave decision to finally come-out, first to her family and friends, and then to the world. Heartbreakingly, overnight, she lost her music career and livelihood, and faced threats and vitriol from traditionalists. Later she developed further health issues from the immense stress and had to rebuild her life almost from scratch. And yet, despite losing so much she has finally found peace. What’s more, Vicky has since become a champion for LGBT equality in the church, as she urges people to celebrate diversity and live authentically.

Now this is quite a controversial read for the leader of our book club to have chosen. You would probably find people in my church of varying beliefs on homosexuality and there certainly are passages in the Bible that denounce it. Interestingly, Vicky does discuss these passages and explains her own interpretations of them, which I found fascinating: being someone who thinks you shouldn’t blindly believe, but instead should question, test and put scripture into context. However whether you believe homosexuality is right or wrong, I can’t see any justification for the absolutely horrible things people said to Vicky. First and foremost for me, Jesus said love each other!

So, in conclusion, I thought Undivided was a moving, raw, all-bared account of Vicky’s inner-struggle with her faith and sexuality. While not relevant to my own faith journey per say, it has opened my eyes to hard it must be for those going through this, and I can see how truly inspiring this book and Vicky must be for other homosexual Christians. Unfortunately, our group has not been able to meet to discuss this book yet, but hopefully we will be able to meet and choose a new book after summer. Good read.

Have you read this? Or any similar books or memoirs?


11 thoughts on “Undivided by Vicky Beeching

    1. Lynn, this really was an eye-opening read – I particularly expected better from the British church. I can’t imagine anyone in my own church treating Vicky so badly, whether they thought homosexuality was right or wrong.

  1. This sounds like a very powerful, personal story. As a Christian myself, I am always ashamed when I hear of such incidents of hatred and prejudice carried out in the name of Christ. Yes, there are indeed passages in the bible which say homosexuality is wrong, but gossiping and telling lies are also stated as being sins, and people are not judged in the same way for these. Most importantly, we are tought not to judge, and that we must emulate Jesus in our own lives, and I think the reverse has happened here. I didn’t realise she was Brittish either, it’s really quite shocking.

    1. Hello Alyson, thank you for stopping by and commenting 🙂 Reading books like this make me sad and ashamed too. I totally agree whether homosexuality is a sin or not, we are not called to judge, especially as we ALL sin in someway, but we should love like Jesus and He was always hanging out with people the religious leaders said were wrong and sinful. I was also shocked to hear Vicky was British – Although the British churches don’t come out looking great in this book, it was the American Evangelical and Mega churches where some of the real damning teaching and worst vitriol seemed to be coming from.

  2. Without wishing to sound as if I’m generalising about all Christians, it always amazes me how a minority seem able to reconcile hate-filled vitriol with their professed beliefs, and also how some sins seem to attract this kind of hate while others are indulged and ignored. I assumed she was American – I’m sorry to see she’s British. I thought the British form of Christianity was more forgiving. As you say, whatever people think about homosexuality, or indeed religion, there’s no excuse for that kind of behaviour.

    1. FF, I couldn’t agree more and I thought the British form of Christianity was more forgiving and open too – I can’t imagine anyone from my own church talking or treating someone so badly. While the British churches Vicky grew up didn’t offer the love, support or healthy teaching I would have hoped for, it really was the American Evangelical and Mega churches where some of the real damning teaching and worst vitriol came from. I recently read Searching for Sunday and in that the author talks about leaving the American Evangelical church because of its anti-gay teachings and views on women within the church too. It is sad.

  3. Excellent review of what I’m sure was an interesting, yet heartbreaking memoir. I read a similar book by Justin Lee entitled “Torn: Rescuing the Gospel From the Gays-vs.-Christians Debate”. As well as telling his story, he also approached the issue from a scriptural basis and I found it quite thought-provoking.

    I use to listen to a CCM radio station quite a bit, yet I’m not familiar with this singer. Perhaps if I research her music I’ll recognize something.

    1. Thank you Kelly – I am pleased I have been able to do justice to this book in my review. It certainly was interesting and heart-breaking, and the Justin Lee book you read does sound similar. I will have to make a note of it. If you look Vicky up you’ll probably recognise some of her songs – she was particularly popular in America’s Evangelical churches – I recognised her song Yesterday, Today and Forever.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.